New Haven's Pizza Shoppe
About New Haven's Pizza Shoppe
New Haven's Pizza Shoppe is a local pizza restaurant located at 137 S Main St, New Haven, KY. The shop is known for its made-from-scratch pizzas and calzones, prepared by the owner, Blane, who manages the operation solo. Customers highlight the unique ordering process through the kitchen, emphasizing a casual, no-frills environment without seating, where orders are typically to-go.
Patrons frequently praise the quality and flavor of the food, describing it as excellent and regionally recognized, with specialties like calzones and creative pizza toppings. The atmosphere is relaxed and informal, and the owner’s personable approach is often noted. Advance ordering is recommended due to the handcrafted nature of the menu items and busy preparation times.
Menu Highlights
Medium Calzone
Cheesesticks
Meat Lovers
-
Cool Guy, food was Great EDI: 12-2-25 JUST ORDERED MORE FOOD ABSOLUTELY AMAZING VERY COOL GOT TO DEAL WITH VERY RELAXED OPEN ENVIRONMENT WILL BE ORDERING AGAIN..
-
I haven’t eaten here yet but I met the owner today while I was out taking my kids for a walk, and he was out bringing his friends dog to the nursing home to see her puppy. My son was super thrilled about seeing the dog. I’ll have to check out the shop sometime. I’ll update my review once I do.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
What are some popular dishes at New Haven's Pizza Shoppe?
The pizza and calzones are highly recommended, especially the Mama Cass calzone and the unique Blane special with cranberries and bacon.
-
Can I make a reservation or is it walk-in only?
New Haven's Pizza Shoppe accepts reservations, but you can also try your luck with walk-ins, especially on weekdays.
-
Do they offer dine-in and takeaway options?
Yes, you can enjoy your meal dining in the cozy and casual space or take away your food, which is great for quick bites.
-
What is the atmosphere like at the restaurant?
It’s a casual, cosy, and quietly trendy spot with a historic feel, perfect for groups, tourists, and solo diners alike.
-
Are there parking and payment options available?
Free street and lot parking are available, and the restaurant accepts both credit and debit cards for payment.
Nearby Pizza restaurants
Are you the owner?
Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.
Claim this page
Terrific made from scratch pizza and calzones, yummy garlic bread w/cheese and sauce for dipping. This is the definition of hole-in-the-wall local dining, which we love. You actually enter through the kitchen, which is also where you pay. The owner, Blane is a fun free-spirited person who loves what he does, and loves singing along to music. He is a hard working one-man-show.